Trot put down firm roots in the 1930s, drawing from the national sensibilities of the colonial period. Ballads mostly deal with love and loss. And dance music from idol groups forms the central axis of K-pop’s ascendance. Developed in different times and in different ways, these three genres of popular music continue to evolve, enjoying extensive popularity among Koreans.
Produced in the 1960s by LKL Records, this 12-inch vinyl record is a collection of Lee Nan-young’s hit songs. The album, a reproduction of 12 popular singles, includes the timeless title track “Tears in Mokpo.”
A song released in 1935 marked the beginning of a new era in the history of Korean popular music. It was “Tears in Mokpo” (Mokpo-ui nunmul) by the legendary singer Lee Nan-young (1916-1965). Decades later, this song is still sung and loved by many Koreans, residents of the southern port city of Mokpo included.
This typical teuroteu norae, or “trot song,” features a two-beat rhythm, minor keys and a pentatonic scale with the fourth and seventh degrees omitted. It was composed by Son Mok-in, based on lyrics by Moon Il-seok, winner of a hometown song contest hosted by Okeh Records earlier that year. The public, regarding the song’s theme of lovelorn longing as a metaphor for sorrow over their colonized homeland, called it a “song of the nation.” Although the musical form was new, the song was eagerly accepted thanks to its lyrics.
Trot songs initially appeared in the early 20th century, when Korea was under Japanese rule. At first, they were generally criticized by those who considered the musical form explicitly Japanese in style, with some even calling it vulgar. However, the Japanese music which was supposed to have influenced trot was in fact of hybrid origin itself. Early on, Japan had been proactive in adopting Western culture and music, and the encounter of Western and Japanese styles produced a new form of pop music called ryukoka, meaning “popular songs.” The version of this genre that was introduced to Korea was called yuhaengga, the Korean equivalent of the Japanese name, before it was renamed as trot in the 1950s. Ryukoka was later renamed enka and exalted to the status of traditional music as Japan attempted to redefine its national identity.
1.The original soundtrack album of “Camellia Lady” (1964), produced by Midopa Records, features 12 songs by six singers. With the success of this album, Lee Mi-ja (1941- ), who sung the title song, was plucked from obscurity and made a star, nicknamed “The Queen of Elegy.” The album brought the second heyday of trot to a music scene that had been dominated by standard pop.
2.This 1972 album by Na Hoon-a (1947- ) was released after the trot singer, at the height of his stardom, signed an exclusive contract with Jigu Records. The title track “Watermill is Turning” earned him the Munhwa Broadcasting Corporation (MBC)’s “10 Best Singers” awards for the fourth straight year.
3.This compilation album released in 1973 by Jigu Records contains 10 songs by five singers. Nam Jin (1946- ), who sung the title track, reigned over the trot scene of the 1970s along with Na Hoon-a, reinvigorating the depressed pop music market.
4.Containing tracks by Cho Yong-pil (1950- ) and the band Young Sound, this split album was released in 1976 by Seorabeol Records. Cho’s “Return to Busan Port” was the highlight of this album which racked up unprecedented sales of over one million copies. The song became widely popular among Korean residents in Japan.
Trot for a Gloomy Era
After Korea was liberated in 1945, trot’s musical characteristics began to change. The pentatonic scale was gradually attenuated and diverse tempos and rhythms were applied – to great success. While the lyrics of earlier songs tended to metaphorically express feelings of love, homesickness or the sorrows of a colonized people, today’s trot has evolved toward more straightforward and candid s of emotion.
Since its emergence in the 1930s, trot has settled into the mainstream of Korean pop music. The secret behind the music’s resilience is its adaptability to changing times. During the wartime years from the outbreak of the Korean War (1950) up to the armistice agreement (1953), trot songs were always there for the displaced, war-torn people, giving vent to their sufferings and consoling their hearts.
A decade later, “Camellia Lady” (Dongbaek agassi) by Lee Mi-ja, a nationwide hit released in 1964, breathed new life into the genre. Musically, it represented typical trot, but the lyrics had a strong down-home feel. Even so, the military government at the time condemned the song as Japanese-style music, and banned it from the airwaves in 1965. The ban would not be lifted until 1987. But in the meantime, trot’s popularity did not wane, instead being continually rekindled by prominent singers like Bae Ho, Nam Jin and Na Hoon-a.
Trot also transformed itself by incorporating other music genres. In the early 1970s, when younger generations embraced rock and folk, several famous singers were involved in a marijuana-related scandal. In response, the authoritarian government launched the so-called “popular music purification movement” to promote “healthy and sound music.” The pop music scene was hit hard; rock in particular earned a bad name, branded as depraved and subversive, which made it hard to find an audience. Then came “rock trot,” combining the two genres, with “Return to Busan Port” (Dorawayo Busanhang-e) by Cho Yong-pil becoming a resounding hit in 1976. Rock musicians looked for ways to survive by adopting elements of public-friendly trot in their music.
After hosting the 1986 Asian Games and the 1988 Seoul Olympics, Korean society grew more open to new trends and the pursuit of fun and enjoyment. Trot saw a resurgence in popularity as entertainment for adults, and the songs released around that time were specifically branded “adult songs.” But the audience for trot music would not remain limited to this demographic group. “Oh my Goodness!” (Eomeona) by Jang Yoon-jeong, released in 2004, was universally loved and sung along to by people of all ages. Trot had once been maudlin music, sad and tear-jerking, but this song showed it could be a means of entertainment to cheer people up and make them laugh.
1.The first (and last) album by Yoo Jae-ha (1962-1987), which was released shortly before his sudden death in a traffic accident. This album contains nine tracks that marked an evolution in ballad music with their progressive sound. It had a substantial influence on later musicians.
2.The first full album by Byun Jin-sup (1966- ), released in 1988, sold over 1.8 million copies, earning him the Best Rookie Award that year and the Grand Prize at the Golden Disk Awards the following year. Byun enjoyed great popularity from the late 1980s to the early 1990s as the “Prince of Ballads,” succeeding Lee Moonsae.
3.Lee Moon-sae (1959- ), who is arguably the doyen of the Korean ballad genre, released his fourth album in 1987. Beginning with his third album, he collaborated with composer Lee Young-hoon (1960-2008), and this famed duo produced an impressive stream of hits.
Romantic Ballads
The word “ballad” comes from the Latin ballare, which means “to dance.” In the Middle Ages, it referred to “a song to accompany dancing,” but the element of dance disappeared over time and ballads came to be known as songs that tell a story. In Korea, on the other hand, the ballad genre covers a wide range of mellow, slow-tempo love songs. Naturally, the lyrics are mostly about romance and the melodies are sweet and sentimental.
The origin of Korean ballads can be found in the “jazz songs” of the 1930s, a domestic genre rooted in Western pop, or in the American-style “standard pop” numbers that would come to be in vogue in the 1960s. However, it was much later that ballad songs took root as a separate genre. The collaborations of composer Lee Young-hoon and singer Lee Moon-sae turned the 1980s into the golden days of the ballad. Byun Jin-sup, who became a star following the release of his first album “To Be Alone” (1988), was also among the earliest ballad singers. And Yoo Jae-ha, who made just one album before his sudden death in a traffic accident in 1987, was praised for taking ballads to another level by melding elements of classical and jazz music. For almost 40 years, the songs of these artists have been in the hearts and minds of Koreans.
A ballad is largely composed of verse and chorus, beginning slowly and building to an emotional climax before coming down again. Singing styles and emotional s have changed with the times. For instance, ballad lyrics are more colloquial today than in the earlier songs of the 1980s. Roughly speaking, two vocal styles tend to be employed: clear and sweet or growling and raspy. A typical Korean ballad singer uses the former, while rock ballad singers often use the latter. Since the 1980s, crossover attempts with rock, R&B and soul have expanded the boundaries of the genre.
Dance Music and K-Pop
Released in 1992, the first album by Seo Taiji & Boys (active 1991-1996) combined dance, metal and rap. It was such a sensation that some divide Korean pop music into the periods before and after Seo Taiji.
The Korean predilection for singing, dancing and drinking has a history dating back thousands of years, as the literature shows. Today’s dance music, however, originated under the influence of Western culture and entered the mainstream only in the 1980s. After the disco craze of the late 1970s, dance-pop with a strong beat and simple composition, such as the songs by Michael Jackson and Madonna, was widely popular, leading to the emergence of music that was similar, yet Korean in style.
Dance music really hit it big in the 1980s when most households came to own color TV sets, making “music for viewing” as important as “music for listening.” The frontrunners of Korean dance music include Kim Wan-sun, Park Nam-jung and the dance trio Sobangcha (Fire Truck). In the 1990s, the influence of hip hop and rock brought new changes in style led by groups like Seo Taiji & Boys. And in the 2000s, the genre went through another significant shift. Big talent agencies embarked on the systematic training of young would-be stars to form what have become known as “idol groups,” mass producing dance music for them and paving the way for the Korean Wave. The international success of Psy’s “Gangnam Style” and his “horse dance,” which went viral in 2012, opened a new page in K-pop history.
Currently, third-generation idol groups, including BTS, Twice, Blackpink and EXO, are popular around the world. Although the proportion of K-pop revenue derived from concerts has diminished over the last few years, the share produced by digital music contents has risen. Idol groups perform songs in a variety of styles, but it’s hard to discuss their choreographed stage shows outside the boundaries of the larger category of dance music.
In fact, there is no clear division between pop music genres, and no artist sticks to just one. After all, a healthy pop music ecosystem is d when various types of music coexist and exchange influences. In this context, Korean popular music has undergone a wholesome evolution, with trot, ballads and dance music waging a three-way race. While trot is now enjoyed by people of all ages, ballads too have maintained their broad appeal with slow, sentimental love songs. And dance music, which drives the K-pop revolution, is demonstrating the potential of Korean popular music to the world.
While trot is now enjoyed by people of all ages, ballads too have maintained their broad appeal with slow, sentimental love songs.
And dance music, which drives the K-pop revolution, is demonstrating the potential of Korean popular music to the world.
1, 2.Psy (1977- ) performs his signature horse dance as he leaves the stage after a press conference at a Gangnam hotel in 2012. The title track of his sixth full album, “Gangnam Style” stayed at second place on the Billboard Hot 100 for seven consecutive weeks.
3, 4.The second full album by EXO, a nine-member boy band (top); and the first mini album by Blackpink, a four-member girl group. The 2000s saw the advent of idol groups with their dance music dominating the music scene, mostly a result of systematic training by big talent agencies.
Zhang Eu-jeongMusic Historian; Professor, College of General Education, Dankook University